Montague, Florida, might not jump out at you like other well-known ghost towns, but it’s a hidden gem brimming with intriguing history. Nestled in Marion County, Montague saw its heyday in the late 1800s and early 1900s. Today, it’s a suburban neighborhood in Ocala, yet there’s a story behind those quiet streets that takes you back to a different time.
Getting there is a breeze. It’s accessible by a simple 2WD vehicle, which means no need for off-road adventures and no hiking. Just find your way near Hwy 464, east of SE38th St. and Maricamp Rd. The coordinates might seem unassuming, but trust me, they lead to a fascinating journey into Florida’s past.
One thing to note is the weather. Summers here can get quite hot, so pack plenty of water if you’re planning a visit then. Otherwise, the climate varies between warm and cool, offering a comfortable experience for most of the year. Technically, there’s no ‘best’ time to visit Montague—each season brings its own charm to the area.
In its prime, Montague was a bustling settlement. Picture a small community coming to life with a general store, post office, and a closely-knit population of about 100 residents by 1911-1912. Today, the only physical remnants of its past are the graves of Rev. John Brooke Pinney and his wife, Ellen Agnes Seward. The fairgrounds have long been sold off, and the area is now known as ‘The Magnolias’—a testament to how places evolve over time.
So, why make the trip? For starters, there’s something uniquely grounding about walking in the footsteps of Florida’s early settlers. While Montague is now part of a growing suburban landscape, understanding its roots adds a layer of richness to any visit. Plus, the story of Rev. John Brooke Pinney alone makes for a fascinating history lesson worth exploring.
The Life and Legacy of Rev. John Brooke Pinney
Rev. John Brooke Pinney’s journey is truly captivating and adds a profound layer to Montague’s history. Born in Baltimore in 1806, Pinney was no ordinary man. His lineage is traced back to Lt. Abraham Pinney, a notable figure, and his early academic endeavors saw him enter Windsor Academy at the tender age of 10 and later graduate from the University of Georgia in 1828.
Pinney’s path took a turn after attending a revival meeting, which ignited his calling to serve as a missionary in Africa, a decision that clashed with his father’s wishes. He found his way to the Princeton Theological Seminary and became the first Presbyterian missionary to Africa. His mission with the American Colonization Society led him to Liberia in 1832, and by 1835, he was acting as the country’s governor. Despite grappling with health issues and various missionary challenges, Pinney’s commitment never wavered.
In the early 1860s, he served as Liberia’s Consul General in the United States, continuing his life’s work of diplomacy and support for Liberia’s colony. After numerous ventures, including attempts at farming and mining across different states, he returned to Africa to assist Liberia College.
By 1879, Montague became Pinney’s home as he bought 240 acres of land and embarked on another chapter of his mission-driven life. He built a private school and church on his property, creating a cornerstone for the Montague community. His efforts left an indelible mark, even though his time there was brief; he passed away on Christmas Day in 1882, with his funeral attended predominantly by the black community.
When visiting Montague, you’ll find that the graves of Pinney and his wife, Ellen Agnes Seward, have been discovered and restored. They stand as the lone historical markers of the town’s early days. Their graves offer a tangible connection to Montague’s rich past and Pinney’s impactful journey.
For more details on Reverend Pinney’s journey and the Shakespearian Ghost Towns of Capulet & Montague, watch my video below:
Montague in the Late 1800s to Early 1900s
Montague wasn’t just some speck on the map during its prime. The town emerged during Florida’s agricultural boom, riding the wave of new settlers in the mid-1800s. People were drawn here by the promise of fertile land and fresh opportunities, especially after Florida joined the U.S. in 1845. Picture a small farming or trading community, typical of rural Florida settlements of that era – that’s Montague for you in its early days.
By 1911-1912, Montague had around 100 residents. Life revolved around a cozy general store and a post office that operated from 1886 to 1915. These were the lifelines for the community, where people gathered, exchanged news, and bought essentials. It was a tightly-knit society where everybody knew everybody.
The community thrived with the expansion of the railroads, a crucial development that brought new growth in the latter half of the 19th century. Railroads meant better transportation for goods like citrus and lumber, which kept towns like Montague buzzing with activity. The post-Civil War period was a time of change, and Montague adapted well initially, likely benefiting from the railroad boom that turned Florida into an agricultural hub.
Montague was more than just a place of economic activity; it had deep social ties, especially connections to freed slaves. During his time in Montague, Rev. John Brooke Pinney’s contributions helped solidify these connections, bringing the community together through his school and church. These ties added a unique layer to the town’s social fabric.
So, what happened? Shifts in agriculture and the economy began to alter the fortunes of many small towns as the 20th century dawned. As larger markets emerged and urbanization increased, Montague, like many other rural communities, started to experience a decline. Hurricanes, citrus freezes, and the natural ebb and flow of economic cycles played their roles, too, gradually shifting people and commerce to more significant hubs.
The Decline and Transformation of Montague
Montague’s decline is a story familiar to many small towns across America. Starting in the early 1900s, shifts in agricultural practices and economic patterns began to affect its growth. Larger markets became more accessible, and improved transportation systems made it easier for people and businesses to move to bigger cities. These changes, combined with naturals such as hurricanes and freezes, gradually emptied Montague of its thriving community life.
A notable turning point was the sale of Montague’s fairgrounds. The land was sold and eventually developed into upscale housing known as ‘The Magnolias.’ This development symbolized the transition from a once bustling settlement into a modern, suburban neighborhood. The new housing brought a different vibe, with the echoes of Montague’s past slowly fading into the landscape.
Today, Montague is a suburban neighborhood in Ocala with a population of around 1,000. Its current status contrasts sharply with its historical roots as a tight-knit, self-sufficient community. The transition reflects a broader trend of urban sprawl, where the lines between once distinct towns and expanding cities blur and merge.
When you visit Montague now, you won’t find the old general store or the post office that once served as community hubs. Instead, you’ll see a modern neighborhood with all the amenities of contemporary living. However, Montague’s past isn’t entirely lost. The graves of Rev. John Brooke Pinney and his wife, Ellen Agnes Seward, have been discovered and restored, providing a tangible link to the town’s fascinating history.
For history buffs and curious visitors alike, Montague offers a unique glimpse into Florida’s past alongside its modern-day transformation. Standing by the old graves, you can’t help but reflect on the passage of time and the stories that once filled the air of this now suburban neighborhood.
Tips for Visiting Montague Today
Exploring Montague in its present form might not be like walking through an old ghost town with crumbling buildings or eerie remnants, but it’s still a rich historical experience. Here’s how to make the most of your visit.
Start your journey at the graves of Rev. John Brooke Pinney and his wife, Ellen Agnes Seward, at 3820-3950 SE 38th Loop in Ocala, Florida. These are the only tangible links to Montague’s history. Their restoration makes them a poignant reminder of the town’s founding days. Take a moment to reflect on the impact Pinney had on the community.
Walk through ‘The Magnolias’ with a sense of the past. While the modern houses and manicured lawns paint a different picture, remember that it’s all built over a town that once bustled with life. Imagine the general store, the post office, and the people who called Montague home.
Chat with locals if you get the chance. Long-time residents might share stories passed down through generations, adding depth to your visit. Not everything is in the history books; personal anecdotes can bring history to life.
Visit during cooler months if you’re not a fan of the summer heat. The weather is much more pleasant, making for a comfortable experience as you explore the area.
Document your visit. Whether through photos, notes, or even a small blog, capturing your experience helps preserve Montague’s story. You might even inspire others to explore this hidden gem.
Even though there are no standing historical structures besides the graves, the neighborhood itself tells a story of transformation. Every visit contributes to keeping the memory of old Montague alive, blending the past with the present.
To view all of the pictures I took in Montague, click here.
If you see this after your page is loaded completely, leafletJS files are missing.