Where Legends Live… and Sometimes Look Back
There’s a quiet corner of St. Augustine where the past doesn’t just linger —
it stares right at you.
Unblinking.
Perfectly still.
Or so they say.
Tucked into the old village is Potter’s Wax Museum, the first wax museum in the United States. From the outside, it looks harmless enough — a quirky slice of history with celebrity likenesses and statesmen dressed in dusty finery.
But deep inside is a room where history gets darker —
a place they call the Chamber of Horrors.
And that’s where our story lives.
A Passion Project… with Sharp Teeth
George Potter founded the museum in 1949 after falling in love with European wax collections. He wanted to bring the same life-like artistry to America — and in St. Augustine, he found his stage.
The main galleries shine with familiar faces. Walt Disney. Einstein. A presidential lineup frozen mid-thought. They’re impressive, a little uncanny, and strangely comforting.
But you don’t come here for comfort.
Not really.
You come for the legends.
The Chamber of Horrors — Where the Stories Bleed Through
It’s not a large room — just a narrow passage lined with scenes from St. Augustine’s darker history. But the moment you step into it, the temperature seems to drop. Voices quiet. The air feels… aware.
Front and center is the story that makes nearly everyone pause:
The Pirate Who Wouldn’t Die
Andrew Ranson — a 17th-century pirate whose life reads like a ghost story even before the haunting begins.
Captured after a failed raid, Ranson was sentenced to die by garrote — a slow, deliberate strangling. Witnesses say the executioner twisted the handle six times before Ranson went limp. Just to be sure, he twisted a seventh.
And the cord snapped.
Ranson fell to the ground.
Still alive.
Franciscan monks rushed in, declared it a miracle, and hid him away before the Spanish governor could finish the job. Eventually, Ranson bargained his way to freedom by helping build Castillo de San Marcos, then even helped defend the city during an invasion. He was pardoned in 1702.
In the Chamber, his wax figure clutches a rosary — his face turned upward, seeking mercy from a world that rarely gave it.
Sometimes, visitors say his eyes look wet.
Sometimes, they swear his mouth moves when the lights flicker.
Sometimes, the room just goes quiet — too quiet.
No one stays long.
Other Faces, Other Fates
The Chamber holds more than Ranson.
There’s Sim Jackson, convicted of killing his wife in 1906 and later hanged.
A wax recreation of his execution stands in a dim corner — rope taut, head bowed.
Some visitors report feeling a sudden pressure in their chest here… like sorrow with nowhere to go.
Others say they feel nothing at all — until they turn their backs.
Wax That Remembers
Most people don’t think of wax as spiritual.
But this room pulls stories through time like threads — history, tragedy, rumor, and pain stitched into silence.
And while Potter’s Wax Museum isn’t known as a paranormal hotspot on its own, this chamber doesn’t need ghosts to feel haunted.
Sometimes atmosphere alone is enough to raise the hair on your arms.
And sometimes… atmosphere is just a word for spirits with better manners.
During nighttime tours, costumed guides retell these stories by lantern-light — giving voice to the legends while waxen eyes gleam in the dark. When you exit, the relief is physical.
You’ll swear the air outside is warmer.
Kinder.
Alive.
Whether anything followed you out…
well.
That’s between you and the hallway lights tonight.
Echo’s Corner
Did You Know?
Ranson’s survival was so unbelievable that Spanish clergy documented it as a miracle. If a pirate can get official sainthood paperwork… anything’s possible.
Haunting Vibe Check:
The Chamber isn’t just scary — it’s intimate.
The figures stand close enough to breathe on you.
Some visitors swear they do.
If You Visit
📍 Location: 31 Orange St., St. Augustine, FL
Time Needed: 45 minutes – 1 hour
Best For: History lovers, theatrical haunt enthusiasts, people who enjoy goosebumps on purpose
Pro Tips:
- Ask about the Chamber of Horrors — it’s not obvious.
- Pair your visit with the Old Jail — it makes a wicked double-feature.
- Go at twilight if you can. The shadows help.
- Bring someone who laughs at fear… or at least pretends to.
Final Thoughts
You won’t hear chains dragging or footsteps behind you inside Potter’s Wax Museum.
No cold spots. No whispered names.
Just stories — old, sharp ones — told through still eyes and silent jaws.
But sometimes what’s scariest isn’t what moves.
It’s what holds perfectly still…
and knows you’re there.
Stay curious, traveler.
And try not to think about who — or what — is staring after you leave. 🕯️
grab your Haunted Museum Checklist — free for TMP readers.
If you see this after your page is loaded completely, leafletJS files are missing.