170 Years, Nearly Gone
Just off Interstate 75 in Sumter County, Florida—close enough to hear the hum of traffic—there’s a small fenced patch of land that most people never notice.
And for a long time, almost no one did.
Wild Cow Prairie Cemetery is one of the oldest burial grounds in the county, established in the mid-1800s when this part of Florida was still very much a frontier. Long before theme parks, highways, or retirement communities, this landscape was open prairie, river crossings, and hard-earned settlements built by people who knew isolation, danger, and resilience as daily companions.
Today, the cemetery stands quietly beside the modern world—a place that nearly vanished, and one that tells a story far bigger than its size.
A Prairie Before Florida Was Florida
In the early 1840s, Florida had only just become a state, and much of the peninsula remained wild, remote, and largely unmapped. In an effort to encourage settlement and create a buffer against ongoing conflict with Seminole tribes, the U.S. government passed the Armed Occupation Act of 1842.
The offer was simple, but unforgiving:
settle the land south of Gainesville, build a home, farm five acres, and be prepared to defend it—literally. In return, settlers would receive 160 acres of land.
Many of those settlers were drawn to a vast open landscape known as Wild Cow Prairie, named for the herds of lean, free-roaming cattle and ponies descended from Spanish livestock left behind centuries earlier. Early accounts describe the area as rich grazing land, alive with birds and wildlife, bordered by wetlands and shaped by seasonal flooding.
At the heart of this prairie flowed the Withlacoochee River, and at a key crossing point, a small settlement began to take shape.
Pemberton Ferry and a Frontier Community
By 1876, that crossing had become Pemberton Ferry, a vital transportation hub linking Sumter and Hernando Counties. Stagecoaches passed through. Steamboats navigated the river. Two busy railroad lines intersected here, connecting this once-isolated community to the rest of Florida.
People didn’t just pass through Pemberton Ferry—they lived here. They raised families, ran businesses, served in public office, and endured the realities of frontier life.
And when they died, they were buried nearby.
In 1849, the first recorded burial took place when William D. Boulden Sr. died from an abscess and was laid to rest overlooking the prairie. That burial marked the beginning of Wild Cow Prairie Cemetery, which would go on to serve the community for more than seventy years.
Among those buried here were town founder James T. Pemberton, veterans of the Seminole and Civil Wars, county commissioners, and pioneer families who helped shape early Sumter County. Historical records also show that the cemetery functioned as a segregated burial ground for white residents—reflecting the deeply unequal social structures of the era—while research suggests that formerly enslaved individuals were also buried here, many in unmarked graves.
Communities like Pemberton Ferry weren’t isolated anomalies—towns such as Croom followed similar paths, rising around industry and transportation before quietly slipping back into the Florida landscape.
When the Town Faded—and the Forest Returned
Like many frontier towns, Pemberton Ferry did not survive the changes of the early 20th century. When the railroad depot moved across the river, the town’s importance declined. By the time the Great Depression arrived, Pemberton Ferry was largely abandoned.
The last known burial at Wild Cow Prairie Cemetery took place in 1924.
Not long after, the federal government purchased the land, which would later become part of the Withlacoochee State Forest. Nature reclaimed the area. Headstones were broken or stolen. Vegetation closed in.
By the early 2000s, an estimated 95 to 98 percent of the original grave markers had been lost.
And then, in 2019, the cemetery came closer to disappearing than ever before. Like many frontier settlements across Florida, Pemberton Ferry faded as transportation routes shifted—much like other once-thriving communities such as Oriole, a nearby Hernando County boom town that vanished when industry and rail access moved elsewhere.
The Cemetery Florida Almost Lost
For decades, Wild Cow Prairie Cemetery sat quietly beside the growing modern world—largely unnoticed, largely forgotten. What remained was a small fenced patch of land surrounded by forest, with only a handful of surviving markers hinting at the dozens of people buried there.
Then, in 2019, attention returned to the site for all the wrong reasons.
Sitting just off Interstate 75 at Exit 309, the land was identified as prime for development. Plans were discussed for a gas station or truck stop—one more convenience stop for travelers rushing past, unaware of what lay just beyond the tree line.
The solution, at least on paper, seemed simple: relocate the visible graves and build over the rest.
But the problem was far more complicated.
Most of the cemetery’s original headstones had already been destroyed. Many graves were unmarked. And historical records suggested the burial ground extended well beyond the small fenced area that remained. Relocating “what was visible” would almost certainly leave others behind—unrecognized, unprotected, and paved over.
Nearly 170 years of history stood on the brink of erasure.
The Fight to Save What Remained
When word of the proposed development reached local researchers and preservation-minded residents, a small group stepped forward to challenge it.
Independent researcher Della Daughtry, along with her husband John, began documenting what was left of the cemetery. They photographed broken markers, traced burial records, and dug through archives to better understand the site’s true boundaries and significance.
Their work led to the formation of the Sumter County Preservation Society, and with it, a determined effort to stop the cemetery from disappearing entirely.
Advocates reached out to county officials. Local explorers and content creators visited the site, sharing its story with wider audiences. What had once been dismissed as vacant land began to be seen for what it truly was—a fragile historic site holding the remains of Florida’s frontier community.
Public pressure grew. The conversation shifted.
But preservationists still faced a critical challenge: proving just how much history remained hidden beneath the surface.
Preservation efforts like those that saved Wild Cow Prairie Cemetery echo similar work at places like the Giddens Homestead Cemetery, where unmarked graves and forgotten burials tell equally fragile stories of Florida’s early families.
What the Ground Revealed
In March of 2020, with county support, ground-penetrating radar was brought in to survey the site.
What it revealed changed everything.
The radar confirmed the locations of the 16 known, marked graves—but it also identified 28 additional unmarked burials, along with four graves outside the existing fence line. The cemetery was far larger than it appeared, and far more intact beneath the surface than anyone had realized.
The pioneers were still there.
This discovery confirmed what researchers had long suspected: Wild Cow Prairie Cemetery was never just the small patch of land people could see. Time, vandalism, and neglect had shrunk it visually—but not historically.
Armed with this evidence, plans to relocate the cemetery were halted. The fence was expanded to protect the newly identified graves, and simple white crosses were placed to mark many of the unrecorded burials, restoring dignity to those who had nearly been lost to history.
Recognition, Preservation, and Visiting Today
The discoveries beneath the soil marked a turning point.
Wild Cow Prairie Cemetery was added to the Florida State Historic Register, and in 2021, it received national recognition when it was listed on the National Register of Historic Places—becoming the first historic site in Sumter County to receive that designation.
In 2022, preservationists, descendants, and community members gathered for a dedication ceremony. Veterans buried here were formally honored. Damaged markers were repaired or replaced. And an official historical marker was installed, finally telling the full story of Pemberton Ferry and the people who built a life on the prairie.
Today, the cemetery is accessible from Exit 309, quietly situated beside the Withlacoochee State Forest. It’s a place that invites visitors to slow down—to read, to reflect, and to recognize that Florida’s past isn’t just found in museums or textbooks.
Sometimes, it’s waiting just beyond the highway.
Why Places Like This Matter
Wild Cow Prairie Cemetery is more than a burial ground. It’s a reminder of how easily history can fade—and how quickly it can be lost if no one is paying attention.
Thanks to the efforts of a small group of determined individuals, this place was given a second chance to be remembered. The prairie still breathes. The stories still linger. And the people who once built a frontier community here are no longer invisible.
If you visit, do so respectfully. Walk the perimeter. Read the marker. Notice how close the modern world comes to brushing past places like this without ever seeing them.
Because beneath Florida’s polished surface, the wild frontier is never truly gone.
It’s just waiting to be rediscovered.
Echo’s Corner
Field Notes from the Edge of the Prairie
One of the most telling pieces of evidence tying Wild Cow Prairie Cemetery directly to the lost town of Pemberton Ferry isn’t a headstone—it’s a map.
A 1937 aerial photograph shows the cemetery sitting squarely within the lived landscape of the former town, aligned with the river crossing, the stagecoach road, and the rail lines that once made Pemberton Ferry a vital transportation hub. What looks today like an isolated patch of woods was once part of a working community—homes, commerce, and daily life unfolding just steps from where the dead were laid to rest.
The last known burial here took place in 1924. The cause of death was listed as dropsy, an old medical term used to describe severe swelling caused by fluid buildup in the body—most often the result of heart or kidney failure. It’s a reminder that these weren’t distant historical figures; they were people who lived long enough to witness the town’s decline, the forest’s return, and the slow fading of the place they once called home.
Perhaps the most unsettling detail? In 2019, this cemetery—holding nearly 170 years of history—was almost replaced by a gas station. The land wasn’t saved because it was loud or famous. It was saved because someone noticed. And sometimes, that’s all the difference history gets.
Visitor Tips: Visiting with Respect
If you choose to visit Wild Cow Prairie Cemetery, here are a few things to keep in mind:
- Pause before entering. This is a historic burial ground and a place of remembrance, not just a roadside stop.
- Stay within the fenced area. The boundaries were expanded to protect unmarked graves—some burials may not be visible.
- Do not touch or move stones. Even damaged or fallen markers should be left exactly as they are.
- Leave no trace. Take only photos and memories; leave everything else undisturbed.
- Be mindful of the setting. You’re visiting a place where families once mourned, not a ruin meant for exploration.
- Read the marker. It tells a story that nearly disappeared—and helps ensure it won’t again.
Wild Cow Prairie Cemetery is easy to miss, but once you stop, it has a way of lingering with you. Visit quietly. Walk slowly. And remember that sometimes, preservation begins with nothing more than paying attention.
Wild Cow Prairie Cemetery isn’t alone in its story. Across Florida, places like Oriole, Croom, and Giddens Homestead remind us how easily communities—and the people who built them—can fade from view. Sometimes, all that remains is a quiet clearing, a few stones, and the choice to remember.
Opt-In Caption
Some places almost disappear—not because they weren’t important, but because no one noticed in time.
If stories like Wild Cow Prairie Cemetery matter to you, consider joining the Travel Made Personal community. You’ll get early access to new Forgotten Friday episodes, behind-the-scenes discoveries, maps, and field notes from places that history nearly left behind.Because every town has a story—and every one of them deserves to be remembered.
If you see this after your page is loaded completely, leafletJS files are missing.